Editor's Note: This guest post is from PoolGenius, a provider of data-driven picks and tools that have helped pool players win at more than three times the expected rate.
Want the secret to making smarter Masters pool picks (and winning your league)? It's not just about making the right Masters picks—it's about making different Masters pool picks than everyone else (without being reckless).
While your competition focuses solely on who might play well based on recent performance and course history, savvy pool players find valuable players that others overlook.
This simple shift in strategy—focusing on pick popularity—can be the difference between another middle-of-the-pack finish and taking home the top prize in your Masters pool.
GET EXPERT MASTERS POOL PICKS
Why Pick Popularity Is Crucial for Masters Pool Picks
Here's why this matters so much: In a Masters pool, your score only matters relative to everyone else's. When 40% of entries select Scottie Scheffler and he plays well, they all rise together. You haven't gained much of an edge.
But what happens when you select a different golfer with similar winning potential who's only in 10% of lineups? If that golfer outperforms Scheffler, you've just jumped ahead of 40% of your pool with a single selection. That's leverage—the real key to winning Masters pools.
Leverage Strategy: A Tier 1 Example
Consider these two hypothetical Tier 1 options for your Masters pool picks:
- Golfer A: 16% chance to win, selected by 42% of your pool
- Golfer B: 13% chance to win, selected by 12% of your pool
The slightly lower win probability for Golfer B is more than offset by the massive popularity advantage. If Golfer B outperforms the other, you've gained significant ground on nearly half the entries in your pool while sacrificing just 3% in win probability.
That’s a trade worth making in most competitive pools. You can enact this strategy across multiple tiers to gain even more leverage.
When (and Where) to Make Your Contrarian Moves
Of course, this is just one example of how to go against the grain and gain leverage over the rest of the field. You don’t have to make your boldest move in Tier 1—in fact, it often doesn’t make sense to do so.
Depending on your scoring system and pool size (more on that shortly), fading one of the top golfers like Scottie Scheffler might be unnecessarily risky. Instead, some of the best leverage opportunities can show up in the lower tiers, where ownership gaps are wider and the drop-off in win probability is smaller.
By waiting until the final few tiers to make your contrarian plays, you can still separate from the field without sacrificing top-end win equity. It's all about picking your spots and matching your strategy to the structure of your specific pool.
Your scoring system and pool size will guide your aggressiveness toward each potential leverage situation.
Pool Size and Masters Pool Picks Strategy
Remember, you don’t need to take huge risks in smaller pools. Playing it relatively safe can still get the job done. But in larger pools, it’s a different game. Making smart leverage plays against the field becomes more important—and the bigger the pool, the more critical that edge becomes—the value of going contrarian scales with pool size.
Small Pools (Under 30 entries)
For smaller Masters pools, one or two strategic leverage plays can create enough differentiation. Focus on finding undervalued players in tiers with the most extreme popularity discrepancy.
Medium Pools (30-100 entries)
As competition grows, your Masters pool picks need more strategic differentiation. Look for 2-3 tiers where you can select capable golfers who are flying under the radar. Of course, the need to be different will scale as you get closer to that 100-entry threshold.
Large Pools (100+ entries)
In large Masters pools, conventional and safe strategies rarely succeed. You'll need multiple leverage plays across different tiers, creating a unique combination that can surge ahead when your picks perform well.
How To Find Masters Pool Pick Popularity
You might be thinking: “Okay, this leverage strategy makes sense—but how do I actually know which players the rest of my pool is picking?”
Sure, you can make educated guesses. Big names, past Masters winners, recent form—those guys usually attract attention. Betting odds also play a role. But guessing only gets you so far.
If you want a real edge, there’s a smarter way to uncover these trends.
The Data-Driven Edge: Beyond Guesswork
Instead of guessing who’s popular, you can know with precision. That’s where the PoolGenius Masters & Majors Pick Product comes in.
PoolGenius analyzes real pick data from several major pool sites and compares that to ranking factors (betting odds, analytics, etc) to find:
- Which players are being overpicked by the crowd
- Which hidden gems are flying under the radar
- Where the biggest popularity gaps—and leverage points—exist in your pool tiers
This isn’t about zagging just to zag. It’s about using actual data to zag only when the math says it’s worth it.
Your Masters Pool Picks Cheat Sheet
All the strategies we’ve discussed? PoolGenius puts it into practice—automatically.
Now available for Masters & Majors pools, PoolGenius builds data-driven entries tailored to your specific format. Just enter your pool size, scoring rules, and tier setup, and it does the heavy lifting.
Instead of relying on gut feel, PoolGenius uses a layered approach that factors in:
- Advanced performance metrics
- Odds, stats, ratings that reflect real win probability
- Pick popularity projections
The result is a smarter, well-balanced entry that gives you a strategic edge—without hours of manual research.
Across all types of sports pools, PoolGenius users have won prizes 3x as often as the expected rate.
If you’re aiming to compete seriously this year, it’s a tool worth having.
