Steelers vs. Colts Odds & Betting Predictions - September 29, 2024
Steelers at Colts
5:00 pm • CBSSteelers at Colts Odds
Spread, Total, Moneyline
MatchupOpenSpreadTotalMoneyline | ||||
---|---|---|---|---|
![]() Steelers 0-1 | +0.5 | -2.5-117 | o41-110 | -135 |
![]() Colts 8-9 | u44.5 | +2.5-102 | u41-110 | +115 |
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/cf8ad/cf8ad768a47debf853c9fc1c64434748eb6f6e9e" alt="location pin"
Lucas Oil StadiumIndianapolis
Steelers vs. Colts Expert Picks
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/46f82/46f821bba76695fa4a0ea9b284ca4a2d63f6ea79" alt="Zense"
Zense
145d ago
Last 30d: 57-52-1 (+6.0u)
IND +2.5-102
0.98u
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/a2ef3/a2ef3b80bb189020e88f9b36c11b2fb10e49ed2b" alt="Gamblers Dream"
Gamblers Dream
146d ago
Last 30d: 16-19-0 (+1.3u)
PIT +13.5 (Live)-105
2.38u
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/5f2de/5f2de5a3c69f9650e658008502c08cde8fd5e927" alt="Shady Biev"
Shady Biev
146d ago
Last 30d: 167-172-7 (+12.6u)
PIT +13.5 (Live)-110
2u
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/0e326/0e326a5b401c6089d897729d6acc1f7e09cad2bd" alt="Boomer Betz"
Boomer Betz
146d ago
Last 30d: 147-105-4 (+58.2u)
G.Pickens u57.5 Rec Yds (Live)-114
1u
Forgot to log from twitter
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/310dc/310dcc36e4f1ca9ac562883f51d1a5eb2847dddb" alt="The Degenerates"
The Degenerates
146d ago
Last 30d: 75-70-4 (-3.9u)
IND u19.5 Team Total-105
1.05u
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/0a4f6/0a4f6ca0f8f185e7bee56b62be52862dbb13bdb9" alt="Action Network Luck Rankings"
Action Network Luck Rankings
146d ago
Last 30d: 9-6-0 (+2.2u)
Over 41-110
0.91u
IND +2.5-105
0.95u
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/21200/212009a7675b6d48bded795f8b0d685d091643c8" alt="JB Bets"
JB Bets
146d ago
Last 30d: 1-2-0 (-1.3u)
G.Pickens 50+ Receiving Yards Yes-132
0.76u
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/29283/29283cd1b96500667acdc99cd3788cee5fedad65" alt="Sir Lockselot"
Sir Lockselot
146d ago
Last 30d: 31-74-1 (-68.0u)
IND +122
2.44u
🔑 Colts ML +122 (FanDuel) 2u
This is ugly and makes no sense but I I just feel this one in my gut. The Colts have not looked good but then why are they only 2.5 point underdogs? Makes no sense. Reading between the lines here, I like the value and think it’s worth the risk. My system grades this out well at a B and +101, again we are getting good value
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/e3ef2/e3ef27ff497a7b90842cce9c2a77d54248e36f84" alt="Ryan Sura"
Ryan Sura
146d ago
Last 30d: 94-93-2 (-3.1u)
M.Pittman o45.5 Rec Yds-110
1u
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/4c9e8/4c9e822519d4eeae537e17821e9c76311a76890f" alt="Simon Hunter"
Simon Hunter
146d ago
Last 30d: 4-1-0 (+5.2u)
IND +2.5+100
1u
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/49237/492377f16a415c3fb9b41e14e97add1f0a2ae653" alt="The Faves Five"
The Faves Five
146d ago
Last 30d: 0-0-0 (+0.0u)
IND +2.5-105
1u
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/27671/276715f5ae51936eb495f3338f87e13f506b3ed9" alt="Mjaybrod"
Mjaybrod
146d ago
Last 30d: 97-77-0 (+14.9u)
J.Fields o39.5 Rush Yds-110
0.91u
Redemption story in Pittsburgh
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/d7a6f/d7a6f97cd066d0a67cc394864a70449678db9d18" alt="Matthew Vincenzi"
Matthew Vincenzi
146d ago
Last 30d: 0-0-0 (+0.0u)
IND +2.5-105
1u
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/3571d/3571d36d6a3f91e5fc33ca7442b5fc6172bb3a7d" alt="Convince Me"
Convince Me
146d ago
Last 30d: 5-8-0 (-3.8u)
IND +2.5-110
0.91u
@The_Oddsmaker
IND o19.5 Team Total-112
0.89u
@nick_giffen
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/aee84/aee84971199c846330bd17bf0f15bf2d608f2f29" alt="Prop Hunter"
Prop Hunter
146d ago
Last 30d: 5-12-0 (-1.1u)
N.Harris o67.5 Rush Yds-120
1.2u
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/4b6dd/4b6dd4495c6c91cf44d77bb974975eb2c003482e" alt="Sean Koerner"
Sean Koerner
146d ago
Last 30d: 13-16-0 (-4.3u)
IND +2.5+100
1u
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/bffb6/bffb6a3e6b3da50a2b339d6310fb595b772380ad" alt="Nick Giffen"
Nick Giffen
146d ago
Last 30d: 20-70-0 (+7.0u)
IND o19.5 Team Total-110
1u
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/6320c/6320cc57162a0beaad911afb2a2987f44b463f60" alt="Capper Central"
Capper Central
146d ago
Last 30d: 60-50-2 (+1.3u)
PIT -135
$1800.00
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/5f2de/5f2de5a3c69f9650e658008502c08cde8fd5e927" alt="Shady Biev"
Shady Biev
146d ago
Last 30d: 167-172-7 (+12.6u)
PIT -2.5-110
1.65u
M.Pittman Anytime TD Scorer Yes+270
1u
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/e3ef2/e3ef27ff497a7b90842cce9c2a77d54248e36f84" alt="Ryan Sura"
Ryan Sura
146d ago
Last 30d: 94-93-2 (-3.1u)
IND +2.5-115
1u
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/df69e/df69e64f530caca5d6fccf6112708e6c47bbf36e" alt="Geoff aka OldManWhoBets"
Geoff aka OldManWhoBets
146d ago
Last 30d: 11-18-1 (-4.2u)
Under 40.5-110
0.5u
FD
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/a87d1/a87d1d83eb22a4f8fba8bd4edb65d9349069a390" alt="SpenceBets"
SpenceBets
146d ago
Last 30d: 2-2-0 (-0.8u)
PIT -2-101
0.5u
10% boost
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/e51fd/e51fdfb37981c9f7317c6c731bbcf768fec021a9" alt="Austin Pendergrass"
Austin Pendergrass
146d ago
Last 30d: 72-122-1 (-29.2u)
N.Harris o64.5 Rush Yds-113
0.5u
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/a629b/a629b9444053a4e6ff532dc9b8ea55c33ed89459" alt="Rocket Plays"
Rocket Plays
146d ago
Last 30d: 36-50-3 (+9.0u)
N.Harris o63.5 Rush Yds-120
1.2u
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/b16a7/b16a78676614a55f20b5e061fa0fda92cec2aec2" alt="Greg Matherne"
Greg Matherne
146d ago
Last 30d: 66-60-3 (+8.7u)
IND +2.5-105
0.5u
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/1f019/1f0190e8746eba9a122c0c5463981f8081514866" alt="Prop Bet Guy"
Prop Bet Guy
146d ago
Last 30d: 0-0-0 (+0.0u)
E.Speed o9.5 Tackles + Ast-135
1u
Speed is over this line in each game this season, and 7/L7 dating back to last season. This should be a fantastic spot for him to rack up the tackles, as the Steelers love to run (3rd highest run play%), and have allowed the third most tackles per game, and the most tackles per game to opposing LBs (per PFF). I don’t have faith in Indy’s offense to be able to move the ball against the Steelers defense either.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/879a5/879a565736f704b9929f3e65af6e9e75db0aab11" alt="Firefighter Bets"
Firefighter Bets
146d ago
Last 30d: 197-155-9 (+27.8u)
N.Cross o6.5 Tackles + Ast-125
0.8u
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/a87d1/a87d1d83eb22a4f8fba8bd4edb65d9349069a390" alt="SpenceBets"
SpenceBets
146d ago
Last 30d: 2-2-0 (-0.8u)
N.Harris o64.5 Rush Yds-113
1.13u
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/f0241/f02416226b71dc9585ed4d90e2776bd058cb316f" alt="Top Shelf Action 🥃"
Top Shelf Action 🥃
146d ago
Last 30d: 508-490-13 (+46.4u)
Over 40-110
0.91u
#ProSystem
… early season over after under
Overall: 80-40-0,67% (ROI:30%)
Season:1-3-0,25% (ROI:-52%)
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/4b6dd/4b6dd4495c6c91cf44d77bb974975eb2c003482e" alt="Sean Koerner"
Sean Koerner
147d ago
Last 30d: 13-16-0 (-4.3u)
M.Pittman u4.5 Recs-125
1.25u
Giving out props on Prop Drop right now
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/392c4/392c4ca87dfbde605dabb8c036bf4be546be38d6" alt="CeeJ Picks"
CeeJ Picks
148d ago
Last 30d: 2-0-0 (+2.4u)
G.Pickens o49.5 Rec Yds-125
1u
Pickens gets a great matchup this week facing the Colts who have been horrible on the defensive side of the ball. IND ranks pass defense ranks 21st and have allowed Nico Collins to have 117 yards and 3 players from the Bears last week to have massive games. Odunze had 112, Moore had 78 and Kmet had 97 yards.
It gets even worse for the Colts as their CB Kenny Moore II was ruled out due to injury. Pickens has been Fields clear top target and I expect them to take advantage this week. Pickens is over this line in 2/3 games this season and in both games he was targeted 7 times.
A.Richardson o0.5 Int-135
1.35u
AR has had a rough start to the season and this week it doesn't get any easier as they get set to take on the Steelers. The Steelers have been surprisingly good to start the season and their defense is the classic Steelers defense we know and love. AR has thrown an interception in all 3 games with 1, 3 and 2.
6 total picks to start the year is not a good thing, especially when you now have to go up against TJ Watt and that Steelers pass rush. The Steelers defense rank 8th in QB hits, 7th in sack % and 2nd in INT %. This pass rush should be able to force some bad decisions out of AR and see hit throw at least 1 pick in this one.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/44a52/44a525a42e12b434f8610a8ec3c7fcf9e933cae9" alt="Nico Terpak"
Nico Terpak
148d ago
Last 30d: 10-17-0 (-12.5u)
IND +2.5-115
1u
Smacking this again at the better number!!
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/bffb6/bffb6a3e6b3da50a2b339d6310fb595b772380ad" alt="Nick Giffen"
Nick Giffen
148d ago
Last 30d: 20-70-0 (+7.0u)
IND +2.5-110
1u
#LuckRankings
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/a9d0d/a9d0d462bd83437f7b7b73125ef5654fbb25507e" alt="Grant Neiffer"
Grant Neiffer
148d ago
Last 30d: 40-39-4 (+4.6u)
A.Pierce o23.5 Rec Yds-110
1.1u
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/1f019/1f0190e8746eba9a122c0c5463981f8081514866" alt="Prop Bet Guy"
Prop Bet Guy
148d ago
Last 30d: 0-0-0 (+0.0u)
M.Pittman u19.5 Longest Reception-115
1.15u
Pittman is under in all three games so far, with a long catch of 13 yards, and an aDOT of 10.3 yards. Low volume passing offense that just got Josh Downs back (he will see more targets than Adonai Mitchell had been), and Alec Pierce has commanded the majority of the deep shots (6 of 13 richardson’s throws 20+ yards down the field).
Brutal matchup against Joey Porter Jr - Steelers are #1 in FTN’s DVOA vs WR1. Porter has only seen 11 targets in three games (13.5% rate), and Pittman’s win rate and separation scores (per Fantasy Points) are both well below avg.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/59458/5945881cca949c643e826d2b89a46887dd58bef6" alt="The Favorites Podcast"
The Favorites Podcast
148d ago
Last 30d: 1-3-0 (-2.4u)
IND +2-110
1u
Simon Says
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/57c1c/57c1c30a1376f6543e7aeb7b186ab18c794312b5" alt="Sunday Six Pack"
Sunday Six Pack
148d ago
Last 30d: 3-3-0 (-0.7u)
IND +1.5-110
1u
Raybon 1
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/7190c/7190c33206761291b9280f58759e5b7087bee176" alt="Nick Martin"
Nick Martin
148d ago
Last 30d: 56-80-1 (-6.9u)
IND +1.5-110
0.91u
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/0024a/0024a216f4443f6607583cd2179d15dfb53bc882" alt="Charlie Wright"
Charlie Wright
149d ago
Last 30d: 4-13-0 (-6.7u)
G.Pickens 80+ Receiving Yards Yes+275
0.69u
And a quarter unit here to finish the ladder. Certainly don’t mind 100+ either.
G.Pickens 60+ Receiving Yards Yes+125
0.63u
Adding half a unit here.
See @PropBomb is on Pickens too 💪💪
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/5990a/5990a960f07c761dcb03e5ebcdd089d35160ab7d" alt="Prop Bomb 🏝"
Prop Bomb 🏝
149d ago
Last 30d: 9-7-0 (+0.9u)
G.Pickens o49.5 Rec Yds-120
1u
Pickens is the unquestioned alpha on the Steelers now without Diontae Johnson averaging 57.0 recyds/ game. He’s had 50+ yards in two of his three games, with one of his misses coming vs. the Broncos where he was covered by the elite CB Pat Surtain II and in a positive game script where the the ran for the sixth-most in the league in Week 2.
In the following week, Pickens saw a Chargers squad that play two-high safety at a top-6 rate (where I purposely target Freiermuth instead) in where the top is covered for big plays and he sees 2.41 YPRR ranking 25th in his position. Despite this, Pickens still saw 7 targets for 57 yards.
But his best matchup has yet to come and that’s this Week vs. the Colts. Not only do they run single-high at top-10 rate, they also are running Cover-3 at the 5th highest rate in the league. Last year, Pickens ranked 4th amongst all receivers averaging 3.54 YPRR in this coverage and is continuing where he left off with 3.70 📈 from 2.31 YPRR regular.
Running his routes primarily out wide, he will avoid slot CB Kenny Moore and face a Colts squad that’s allowed the 4th-most PPG toward the perimeter. Players who fit this description they’ve faced include Doubs (62), Collins (117), Moore (78), & Odunze (112). Pickens is one of the best separators in the league so this is a ceiling spot waiting to happen. #PlayerProps
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/0024a/0024a216f4443f6607583cd2179d15dfb53bc882" alt="Charlie Wright"
Charlie Wright
149d ago
Last 30d: 4-13-0 (-6.7u)
G.Pickens o48.5 Rec Yds-131
1u
Excellent matchup for Pickens. He was 6th among WRs in yards per route run against single high/middle field closed looks in 2023.
IND leads the league in Cover 3 (one-high safety) coverage. Outside receivers have torched them this season (Collins, Moore, Odunze).
Volume is a question, but he should produce when PIT chooses to pass.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/27671/276715f5ae51936eb495f3338f87e13f506b3ed9" alt="Mjaybrod"
Mjaybrod
149d ago
Last 30d: 97-77-0 (+14.9u)
M.Pittman o45 Rec Yds-110
0.91u
Dude has been a ghost for 3 weeks
Over 40-110
0.91u
Pittsburgh should never be in the 40’s
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/acabb/acabb78b8dcf5ac8f7f84715a4ac1289cddca61b" alt="Sandy Plashkes"
Sandy Plashkes
149d ago
Last 30d: 98-97-7 (+5.6u)
IND +1.5-110
1u
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/56484/5648458853c0908ec6ccf250d91b36b9bb3ddbe3" alt="Picks Office"
Picks Office
149d ago
Last 30d: 83-86-2 (-11.9u)
Under 40-110
1u
Follow On X: https://x.com/PicksOffice
The Pittsburgh Steelers’ defense has been their cornerstone, and after allowing just 8.7 points per game in their first three outings, this trend shows no signs of fading. Pittsburgh held their last opponent, the Chargers, to a mere 10 points, and that included a second-half shutout. With the Colts' offense sputtering as they average only 19.3 points per game, this sets up for a low-scoring contest. The Colts have also shown inefficiency on third downs, converting just 32.3%, and have been error-prone with Anthony Richardson already throwing six interceptions. Both teams come into this game with weak passing offenses, as the Steelers average only 158.3 passing yards per game, while the Colts are slightly better at 184.3 yards. Pittsburgh’s third-down defense, allowing less than 40% conversion rates, will make it even harder for Indianapolis to sustain drives.
Historically, the Steelers have consistently hit the under when they’re road favorites coming off a win. Thirteen of their last 14 games in this scenario have fallen below the total, which supports the case for a defensive battle. The Steelers' offense has also been far from explosive, putting up just 17 points per game despite their undefeated start. While Najee Harris has been solid on the ground, averaging around 70 yards per game, Pittsburgh’s lack of explosive plays in the air means they’re not built to run away with high-scoring contests.
On the Colts' side, while Jonathan Taylor had a breakout game with 110 yards in the Colts’ victory over Chicago, their passing attack has been a liability. Richardson’s completion percentage sits under 50%, and with Pittsburgh’s stout defense, there’s a high likelihood that he will struggle to move the ball effectively. Indianapolis’ inability to stretch the field with deep passing threats further reduces the chances of a shootout. The Steelers' defense, ranked among the top in points allowed, will focus on shutting down Taylor, forcing Richardson into uncomfortable passing situations where he’s already shown a tendency for turnovers.
In summary, both teams lean heavily on their defenses, and with the Steelers' suffocating performance through three weeks and Indianapolis' inconsistent offense, this game has all the makings of another low-scoring affair. The combination of sluggish offenses and strong defenses points to the under being the most likely outcome.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/60e30/60e30ea54521cb7d7542dcf9588d1fa2a32fcbf4" alt="Chris Gimino"
Chris Gimino
149d ago
Last 30d: 9-5-0 (+3.9u)
PIT -1.5-110
1u
I don’t normally like to bet sides but I see some concerning things for the Colts here in the matchup.
The Colts haven’t possessed the ball for more than 57 plays in a game, while allowing their opponents possess the ball for massive totals above 70 and even 80 plays. This is almost precisely the inverse of the Steelers, who win close games against tough opponents with sustained drive possession.
So now layer this on to the matchup of Colts offense vs. Steelers defense. Is it easier to see Anthony Richardson dropping 60 yard explosive chunks and / or ground game dominance against a top 5 DVOA defense? Or is it easier to forecast more outcomes where the Steelers bottle up the Colts on early downs, and force a young QB into negative plays and mistakes on 3rd down? Which would lead to change of possession, which would lead to a lot of Arthur Smith controlling the clock on offense.
I think we see another snoozer here won by PIT.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/a9d0d/a9d0d462bd83437f7b7b73125ef5654fbb25507e" alt="Grant Neiffer"
Grant Neiffer
149d ago
Last 30d: 40-39-4 (+4.6u)
M.Pittman o45.5 Rec Yds-111
1u
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/f04a1/f04a1402ad9c8b641c6d3be67dce642da814b106" alt="Markus Markets"
Markus Markets
149d ago
Last 30d: 43-53-4 (+3.7u)
G.Pickens o47.5 Rec Yds-120
0.83u
Fliff
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/ca07d/ca07d1585e5311f70b97830a8fe4a78cc16b66fb" alt="Green Dot Daily"
Green Dot Daily
150d ago
Last 30d: 0-0-0 (+0.0u)
IND +1.5-109
0.92u
@ChrisRaybon
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/9c8d5/9c8d554258bc61e3a63875a1b81c117703d82f34" alt="Chris Raybon"
Chris Raybon
150d ago
Last 30d: 3-4-0 (-1.4u)
IND +2-110
0.91u
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/e239e/e239ed2da589a032e18ccf35fe97ffa9e08b349d" alt="Cam Is Money"
Cam Is Money
150d ago
Last 30d: 191-149-12 (+20.9u)
G.Pickens o49.5 Rec Yds-115
0.87u
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/ca07d/ca07d1585e5311f70b97830a8fe4a78cc16b66fb" alt="Green Dot Daily"
Green Dot Daily
151d ago
Last 30d: 0-0-0 (+0.0u)
IND +2-110
0.91u
@SimonHunterNFL
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/adf85/adf85fa2076eec6558a6c8f908350c1dd0e2a049" alt="Chad Millman"
Chad Millman
151d ago
Last 30d: 4-2-0 (+0.3u)
IND +2-108
0.93u
Simon Says bet during our recording of @TheFavoritesPodcast.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/44a52/44a525a42e12b434f8610a8ec3c7fcf9e933cae9" alt="Nico Terpak"
Nico Terpak
151d ago
Last 30d: 10-17-0 (-12.5u)
IND +1.5-105
1u
Simon says per @TheFavoritesPodcast my model makes this colts -0.5
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/0e326/0e326a5b401c6089d897729d6acc1f7e09cad2bd" alt="Boomer Betz"
Boomer Betz
151d ago
Last 30d: 147-105-4 (+58.2u)
IND +2.5-110
0.45u
Give me +3
IND +1.5-110
0.91u
Lookahead. Adding more if line moves
PICKEM
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/deb14/deb144c1493f3ecdeba07b19d2b86c28c634a313" alt="Matt Moore"
Matt Moore
152d ago
Last 30d: 36-46-2 (-2.4u)
Under 38.5-110
1.1u
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/82f8c/82f8c439f8fee842d6e658a8b9b97ce5f1f341fa" alt="Brandon Anderson"
Brandon Anderson
152d ago
Last 30d: 31-63-1 (+12.3u)
Under 40-110
0.5u
Lookahead u41 already down to 38.5 some books, DK asleep at the wheel, grab the key while it’s there
Under 41-109
1u
Week 4 Lookahead
PRO Insights
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/99008/99008e988044549d24fcaeec8b7b6a2008d4db6e" alt="Steelers logo"
Steelers
PIT Insights
- Featured Insight
The Steelers have allowed their opponents to be successful on 38.0% of plays against motion since the 2023 season -- T-best in NFL; the Colts have been successful on 37.0% of plays they have run with motion since the 2023 season -- 4th-worst in NFL.
TRY FOR FREE
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/9eed6/9eed679021c113aba6ae0c732a49897093c0e3c8" alt="Colts logo"
Colts
IND Insights
- Featured Insight
The Colts have averaged 26.3 receiving yards per game allowed to RBs this season -- 10th-best in NFL; Steelers RBs have 24.3 receiving yards per game this season -- 7th-worst in NFL.
TRY FOR FREE
Steelers vs. Colts Previews & Analysis
Steelers vs. Colts Props
Prop Projections
There are no prop projections found for the selected slate. Please check back later.
Prop Odds Comparison
Line Movement Tracker
Steelers vs. Colts Public Betting Percentages
Betting Trends
- Colts are 3-2 in their last 5 games.
- Colts are 4-1 in their last 5 games against the spread
- Colts are 4-5 in their road games against the spread
- The totals have gone OVER in 3 of Colts' last 5 games
- The totals have gone OVER in 5 of Colts' 8 last games at home
Matchup History
Against the Spread (ATS) History
Over/Under History
Last 5 Matchups
Steelers vs. Colts Injury Updates
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/99008/99008e988044549d24fcaeec8b7b6a2008d4db6e" alt="Pittsburgh Steelers logo"
Steelers Injuries
- Montravius AdamsDT
Adams is questionable with knee
Questionable
- Cole HolcombLB
Holcomb is out with knee
Out
- Calvin AndersonT
Anderson is questionable with groin
Questionable
- C.J. HendersonCB
Henderson is out with neck
Out
- Dylan CookT
Cook is out with foot
Out
- Roman WilsonWR
Wilson is out with hamstring
Out
- Mason McCormickOL
McCormick is questionable with hand
Questionable
- Logan LeeDE
Lee is out with calf
Out
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/9eed6/9eed679021c113aba6ae0c732a49897093c0e3c8" alt="Indianapolis Colts logo"
Colts Injuries
- Braden SmithT
Smith is out with personal
Out
- E.J. SpeedLB
Speed is questionable with knee
Questionable
- Matt GayK
Gay is questionable with neck
Questionable
- Cameron McGroneLB
McGrone is questionable with elbow
Questionable
- Anthony RichardsonQB
Anthony Richardson downgraded to out Week 17.
Out
- JuJu BrentsCB
Brents is questionable with knee
Questionable
- Jaylon CarliesDB
Carlies is questionable with knee
Questionable
Team Stats
Steelers vs. Colts Odds Comparison
Could not load odds
Steelers at Colts Team Totals
MatchupOverUnder | ||
---|---|---|
![]() Steelers 0-1 | o21.5-102 | u21.5-114 |
![]() Colts 8-9 | o19.5-118 | u19.5+101 |